A while back (as in, before the holiday season), I was on a big cookie kick. When I realized I couldn't go to Dom's department's holiday party, I still wanted to make some treats to send with him, so I chose a
glazed lemon cookie recipe from Real Simple. These turned out pretty well, to say the least.
My notes:
- While gathering all the ingredients together, I realized that the only lemon flavour came from the glaze; there was neither lemon juice nor zest in the dough itself. I ended up using the zest of one lemon and the juice of about 1/2 a lemon in the dough, added with the egg yolks, salt, and vanilla. A bit of raw dough was nicely flavoured before baking, but if anything, I should have use more juice or zest to get a stronger flavour in the baked cookies.
- The extra lemon juice helped pull the dough together; perhaps because our apartment is frightfully dry, the dough was really crumbly after adding the flour. Adding enough lemon juice helped smooth everything out and imparted some lemon flavour to the dough itself.
- The recipe claims to produce 48 cookies. I don't know if I did something wrong or what, but I came out with 32 cookies (two sheets of 18). It's not even like I made them gigantic--they came out to a perfect two-bite cookie. So I'm not sure what that was about, but it didn't seem to be any kind of a problem.
- Each sheet of 18 got about 13 minutes in the oven--neither brown nor very underbaked, but perfect for us.
- I drizzled the glaze over the cookies rather than dipping the cookies in the glaze. This had the double effect of using less sugar (probably about half of what the recipe called for, but I just added sugar to the lemon juice until I got glaze, so I have no idea how much I actually used) and making the cookies look all fancy.
- From a subsequent trial of the cookies in which I didn't add any lemon zest to the glaze for aesthetic reasons, I found that the lemon flavour in the glaze was not as strong. So next time I make these, I'd sacrifice the aesthetics of a totally smooth glaze for the stronger flavour provided by the zest.
I have extremely high standards when it comes to my own baking. Usually I pronounce what I create as "all right", but I almost always have a "but..." to go along with it. Not so with these. As soon as I bit into one of these I knew this was a recipe to keep (with all the modifications, of course). A bright, clean, intense lemon flavour, not too sweet, not too dry, not under- or over-baked, and just enough cookie to get a good taste without having too much cookie. What else do you need?
 |
Delicious. |
 |
I may have taken one already... |